‘VAR’y of mistakes: Premier League looks ahead for a better future in refereeing

The VAR, having started in the Premier League from the 2019-20 season, has led to some questionable decisions, with the most recent being Cody Gakpo’s goal disallowed.

Published : May 23, 2023 22:12 IST , Chennai - 4 MINS READ

The mistakes in the Premier League have been acknowledged by the PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Board), the body handling the refereeing in the league, citing ‘human error’. 
The mistakes in the Premier League have been acknowledged by the PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Board), the body handling the refereeing in the league, citing ‘human error’.  | Photo Credit: Getty Images
infoIcon

The mistakes in the Premier League have been acknowledged by the PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Board), the body handling the refereeing in the league, citing ‘human error’.  | Photo Credit: Getty Images

The Liverpool faithful heaved a sigh of relief when they thought Cody Gakpo had equalised for the home team against Aston Villa in the 55th minute in a recent Premier League match.

But VAR officials, sitting over 200 miles away, asked referee John Brooks to re-evaluate his decision on the pitch-side monitor and the goal was soon overruled for an offside.

Liverpool defender Virgil van Dijk had received the ball after a deflection off Villa defender Ezri Konsa and his cross was steered into the net by Gakpo. But as Konsa’s deflection was seen as ‘not deliberate’, van Dijk was deemed to be in an offside position.

Goal or no goal? The Liverpool fans thought Cody Gakpo had equalised only to see it get overturned eventually.
Goal or no goal? The Liverpool fans thought Cody Gakpo had equalised only to see it get overturned eventually. | Photo Credit: AP
lightbox-info

Goal or no goal? The Liverpool fans thought Cody Gakpo had equalised only to see it get overturned eventually. | Photo Credit: AP

A late Roberto Firmino goal salvaged a point for the Reds, but the referee’s decision of disallowing Gakpo’s goal has come under criticism from many quarters, including the Liverpool manager Jurgen Klopp.

“I asked the ref why the goal was offside because offside situations should be clear, but he explained it to me,” Klopp said. “He said it was a subjective decision. He thinks it is a not deliberate action from the defender, but I think it is. And I think the VAR wasn’t sure.”

This is not the first time that refereeing decisions, especially the ones involving the VAR, have caused a stir.

In February this year, Ivan Toney’s equaliser against Arsenal – which should not have stood – was awarded to Brentford, leading to Video Assistant Referee Lee Mason stepping down from his job.

On the same day, Pervis Estupinan’s goal for Brighton was denied against Crystal Palace as Roberto De Zerbi’s side dropped two points with a draw.

Brooks was in the VAR room for that game.

Learning from mistakes

The slip-ups and mistakes in the league have been acknowledged by the PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Board), the body handling Premier League refereeing citing ‘human error’.

That is something that the league will look to avoid and improve VAR, Neil Saunders, the director of the Premier League told Sportstar.

“Working with the PGMOL, which Howard (former referee Howard Webb) came in and joined at the back end of last year as our Chief Referee Officer, we’ve developed our Elite Referee Development Plan (ERDP),” he said.

“We’re coming to the end of the first year of that plan which is to elevate the quality of coaching so that we’ve got world-leading referees in the workforce in England.”

The Premier League, through its Elite Referee Development Plan and with the help of former referee and the current PGMOL chief, is looking to improve the present and future of refereeing in the UK.
The Premier League, through its Elite Referee Development Plan and with the help of former referee and the current PGMOL chief, is looking to improve the present and future of refereeing in the UK. | Photo Credit: Getty Images
lightbox-info

The Premier League, through its Elite Referee Development Plan and with the help of former referee and the current PGMOL chief, is looking to improve the present and future of refereeing in the UK. | Photo Credit: Getty Images

The league has followed the path of the EPPP (Elite Player Performance Plan, a project targeted at young footballers) to develop more match officials, including referees, to match global standards.

In the 2018 FIFA World Cup, there were no referees from England for the first time in 80 years. Four years later, in Qatar, that figure stood at just two out of 35.

“Our work with the PGMOL – who are ultimately responsible for the referees – is to try and support the referees to make them the best in class,” Saunders said.

“To support the development of those referees that are there in the Premier League at the moment but also to support the future, the development of the pipeline of talent to come through and referee in the Premier League in years to come.”

He also added that the VAR is also ‘part of the plan’ and that it will only improve in the upcoming seasons.

The VAR, having started in the 2019-20 season, saw in-game referee conversations being released for the first time when Webb discussed the VAR calls with pundits Gary Neville and Jamie Carragher.

Unlike field hockey – where the talks between the referees on and off the field during VAR decisions are completely public – VAR calls in football are confined only between the referees because FIFA forbids releasing the talks during the game.

But Webb, along with Neville and Carragher, discussed the decisions with the audio after the games.

“I hope tonight’s been a good insight as we’ve revealed how officials communicate and some of the rationale behind the decisions. Going forward we want to do more of the same,” Webb said on Sky Sports.

Sign in to unlock all user benefits
  • Get notified on top games and events
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign up / manage to our newsletters with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early bird access to discounts & offers to our products
Sign in

Comments

Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide to our community guidelines for posting your comment