AUS vs IND: Get rid of umpire's call, says Daryl Harper

The former ICC elite panel umpire says there are still “deficiencies in either the communication or the understanding” of the concept.

Published : Jan 02, 2021 12:00 IST , Sydney

Former Australian ICC elite panel umpire, Daryl Harper. - GETTY IMAGES
Former Australian ICC elite panel umpire, Daryl Harper. - GETTY IMAGES

Former Australian ICC elite panel umpire, Daryl Harper. - GETTY IMAGES

Former ICC elite panel umpire Daryl Harper has suggested the contentious Umpires’ Call in the Decision Review System (DRS) be banned, saying there were still “deficiencies in either the communication or the understanding” of the concept after over a decade of its implementation.

The Umpires’ Call usually comes into use if a review has been sought for LBW. In a situation where the umpire has ruled not-out, even if the ball is shown to be hitting the stumps on review, the TV umpire has no power to change the decision.

The only consolation for the bowling team is that its review remains intact.

“I’ve had enough of Umpire’s Call. Let’s just ban Umpire’s Call. Get rid of the controversy and just go with it. Any contact with ball on stump will dislodge a bail. No 48 per cent, 49 per cent,” Harper was quoted as saying by the Sydney Morning Herald .

“The fact it’s been going for 12 years and the public are still mystified, and the players are still mystified, would suggest that there are some deficiencies in either the communication or the understanding,” he added.


Harper reckoned the concept was flawed and urged the ICC to thoroughly revisit it.

“So there needs to be some serious work done from the ICC’s end. Because we shouldn’t be talking about umpiring decisions,” Harper said.

The recently-concluded Boxing-Day Test between India and Australia in Melbourne involved a few contentious umpiring calls. Australia captain Tim Paine was given out caught behind off Ravindra Jadeja on the third day. He was ruled out after the on-field call by Paul Reiffel was overturned by third umpire Paul Wilson. The wicketkeeper-batsman didn’t hide his disappointment over the decision while leaving the field.

“You could get 10 Indians in a room and 10 Australians in a room and they would see the Tim Paine run out in the first innings, and the 10 Indians would say ‘oh that’s out’ and the 10 Australians would say ‘oh that’s not out,’” Harper said.

“If there’d been another picture in between the two we were looking at, I think we probably could have ruled him out. So the technology after 12 years of this, it still isn’t up to scratch,” he added.

ALSO READ | Warner doing everything he can to play in Sydney

In the same match, Australian batsmen Joe Burns and Marnus Labuschagne were lucky to survive LBW appeals despite replays showed the ball would have gone on to clip the bails, prompting Sachin Tendulkar to raise doubts about the concept.

“I am not convinced with the DRS rule at all. Once you have gone upstairs to the third umpire then the on-field umpire’s decision should not come into the picture at all,” Tendulkar said on his YouTube channel.

“It doesn’t matter whether the ball is hitting 10 per cent or 15 per cent or 70 per cent because when you get bowled, none of this matters. I understand that the tracking system is not 100 per cent accurate but can you name one umpire who has never made a mistake?” He said it was unfair on the bowlers.

“Even if the ball is just clipping the bail and the umpire has given not out, that decision should be overturned when they have referred to the third umpire. It (umpire’s call) is too confusing and somewhere it is unfair to bowlers also.”

Sign in to unlock all user benefits
  • Get notified on top games and events
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign up / manage to our newsletters with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early bird access to discounts & offers to our products
Sign in


Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide to our community guidelines for posting your comment