Vettel or Leclerc — does Ferrari need to choose a leading man?

Charles Leclerc and Sebastian Vettel both want to be the main man at Ferrari, making life a little tricky for team officials.

Published : Sep 30, 2019 16:51 IST

The battle to be the main man at Ferrari appears to be bringing the best out of both Charles Leclerc and Sebastian Vettel.
The battle to be the main man at Ferrari appears to be bringing the best out of both Charles Leclerc and Sebastian Vettel.

The battle to be the main man at Ferrari appears to be bringing the best out of both Charles Leclerc and Sebastian Vettel.

It is not an issue Ferrari could have imagined having to consider a matter of weeks ago.

The Scuderia had not won a single race heading into Formula One's mid-season break, with a variety of woes hampering new man Charles Leclerc and Sebastian Vettel appearing a shadow of his former self. But despite Mercedes' one-two in Russia on Sunday, both men have hit form and that has given Ferrari a bit of a problem.

For two weeks running, the inexperienced Leclerc has fumed that four-time champion Vettel has found himself in the lead despite lagging in qualifying.

The team's tactics have scarcely come under greater scrutiny, even if Leclerc remains diplomatic in public — seemingly happy to forget his team radio rants the moment he leaves his SF90.

"I think everything was respected," he said in Sochi, wilfully ignoring his earlier complaints that Vettel was taking his time to accommodate a position swap after Leclerc "played the team game."

In Singapore, where Leclerc raged Vettel's undercut was "not fair," the 21-year-old similarly backtracked: "In the car, it's frustrating and then, as soon as I thought a little bit more of the situation after it, you see the things maybe a bit differently."

The Monegasque could pile further pressure on his team by starting to stand by his mid-race thoughts in the hours and days that follow. So we weigh it up: does Ferrari need to choose between the two drivers?


The radio squabbling might not be a good look, but Ferrari could understandably care little if it continues to perform on the track. There was comparatively little tension between Leclerc and Vettel earlier in the season when neither driver was winning.

Now, the Scuderia have had four straight poles — all for Leclerc — and gone on to win on three of those occasions. Only an MGU-K failure in Vettel's car that forced him to retire and enabled Lewis Hamilton to pit under the virtual safety and retain the lead denied them another victory in Russia.

The battle to be the main man at Ferrari appears to be bringing the best out of both stars.


In 2018, it was Mercedes which was at the centre of a team tactics storm. Valtteri Bottas went the entire season winless but would have had victory at the Russian Grand Prix had he not been ordered to allow Hamilton through.

Of course, the chief difference between the situation there and at Ferrari is that Hamilton won the drivers' championship and Mercedes collected the constructors' title, justifying their decisions.

By the start of this season, the Silver Arrows were on the same page, beginning with five straight one-twos — including a pair of Bottas wins.


Mercedes may have two stars, but it also boasts a clear leading man — unlike the Scuderia. Bottas was permitted to take on Hamilton early in 2019 but can be under no illusion when it comes to the identity of the team's star.

Hamilton extended Mercedes' winning run through eight Grands Prix this year and is on course for a sixth championship — his third in a row.

Vettel cannot claim to have this season shown the experience and quality that led him to four titles, with Leclerc performing in a superior manner. The former champion and the up-and-comer can each justifiably feel they deserve special treatment — and Ferrari has so far found itself stuck in the middle.

While its chances of hunting down Hamilton this season appear extremely slim, the Italian outfit has shown potential for 2020.

In order to provide a consistent challenge to Hamilton's crown, it must surely choose its own contender and back him week after week and avoid the confusion of these debates.

Sign in to unlock all user benefits
  • Get notified on top games and events
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign up / manage to our newsletters with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early bird access to discounts & offers to our products
Sign in


Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide to our community guidelines for posting your comment