Hawk-Eye apologises after goalline error costs Sheffield win at Villa

Sheffield Shield had a goal ruled out in the first half despite the ball crossing the goalline as Hawk-Eye apologised for the gaffe.

Published : Jun 18, 2020 11:57 IST , BIRMINGHAM

Sheffield United players inquire referee Michael Oliver about the goalline clearance by Aston Villa goalkeeper Orjan Nyland.
Sheffield United players inquire referee Michael Oliver about the goalline clearance by Aston Villa goalkeeper Orjan Nyland.

Sheffield United players inquire referee Michael Oliver about the goalline clearance by Aston Villa goalkeeper Orjan Nyland.

Operators of Premier League's goalline technology system apologised for an error caused during the Wednesday's goalless draw between Sheffield United and Aston Villa on Wednesday.

In the Premier League's first match after a 100-day hiatus due to the COVID-19 crisis, Sheffield United was denied when Villa goalkeeper Orjan Nyland carried the ball back over his own line in a clumsy defensive mix-up just before halftime.

"I dont know whether to laugh or cry," Sheffield United manager Chris Wilder said after the game, which was played behind closed doors at Villa Park.

"The feeling at the time by everybody, both sets of players and staff, was that of a goal."

Off-balance Villa goalkeeper Nyland caught a curling free kick but was bundled back over the line by team mate Keinan Davis.

Referee Michael Oliver, pointing to his watch, looked to indicate that goalline technology had not verified the ball had crossed the line, despite what appeared to be clear evidence on TV replays. This had a huge impact on the final result as the match ended 0-0.

Hawk-Eye, which operates the goalline system, issued a statement after the game saying the seven cameras in the stands around the goal area were obstructed by the keeper, defender and goalpost.

"This level of occlusion has never been seen before in over 9,000 matches that the Hawk-Eye Goal Line Technology system has been in operation," the company said, while fans furiously vented on social media about the technological slipup.


There was also no intervention from the Video Assistant Referee despite TV viewers being able to see the ball had clearly crossed the line.

Under the IFAB protocol, the VAR is able to check goal situations, however due to the fact that the on-field match officials did not receive a signal, and the unique nature of that, the VAR did not intervene, the PGMO, body responsible for match officials in English professional football, said in a separate explanation.

Wilder asked to speak to Oliver at halftime.

"The referee said it had the feel of a goal but he has to rely on Hawk-Eye. We believe it should have been referred and asked for it,” he said.

The draw moved Sheffield to sixth in the standings, one point behind Manchester United.

VAR in a straitjacket

Following the incident, former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher questioned the limitations of VAR for not intervening when goalline technology failed.

“I have to say I think goalline technology coming into football has been one of the best things ... they (United) are rightly disappointed but the technology in general has been amazing,” Carragher told Sky Sports.

“I go back to the idea that VAR has been in a straitjacket: we can only do 'this'.

“It doesn't matter how you get to the right decision. It's goalline technology but are they (VAR) not in the referee's ear, speaking to people running the technology?

“Rather than all these protocols, they should be saying, 'OK, you've made a mistake, we'll step in.'"

Sign in to unlock all user benefits
  • Get notified on top games and events
  • Save stories to read later
  • Access to comment on every story
  • Sign up / manage to our newsletters with a single click
  • Get notified by email for early bird access to discounts & offers to our products
Sign in


Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide to our community guidelines for posting your comment